Well, this thread seems to be an excellent example of why I do not like to get involved in most of the larger site plot. Because no one can ever seem to agree or get along. When I have a small plot with just one or two other people, I can always find a way to compromise on what I want to happen or what he/she wants to happen. We can work it out.
Also, threads do not get completely out of control if I can’t post one day. I am a college student and I do not always have time to post in every thread I am in every single day. This becomes a problem when I am involved in a mass thread, because if I don’t post for one day, there might be 15-20 posts between the last one and the one I am about to make, which makes it basically impossible for me to write one that covers everything that has happened.
I think one of the big problems with the Death Eaters and the Order and the Ministry never having any plot is that no one on this site every wants to be vulnerable or lose at anything. There are some characters that are especially guilty of this, but it is sort of a problem on the whole. Of course, no one creates a character thinking that it would be okay if he/she died. We grow attached to our characters, and they take a lot of time to make. But occasionally, our characters should get hurt in battle, have weaknesses, be bad at something. They are human. But I just don’t see things being played that way.
And that is another reason why I mainly stay out of larger plots. What is the point of me expending effort to promote a plot or further a story when it is just going to dissolve into chaos or yet another argument? I would rather have a set of smaller plots set up that all sort of revolve around the same thing, some way that individuals could post in groups of 2-4 in threads that perhaps are happening at the same time in different places, or even simultaneously in the same place. That way, when people are not posting realistically, their nonsense doesn’t just get lost in a mass thread where some posts are good and others are, well… not. They would have to be more responsible for what they write because someone is more likely to call them out on it when it directly affects the fate of the thread.
These are just thoughts. I guess I don’t really have that much clout in this situation because Remy is basically an unranked Death Eater that hasn’t really participated in much in the overarching DE/Order/Ministry plot, but I have already given my reasons for that. I do think she is an active, realistic character, though, whom I have grown very fond of writing.
As for DE's taking over Hogwarts, I did ask Darren if Remy could be appointed to the Care of Magical Creatures position so she could carry out Sandra’s wishes of finding out the students’ views on the current war, but I never heard back so that has basically stopped.
That's about it from me. Feel free to give me your thoughts on any of this.