Elijah didn’t seem perturbed by her observations, something which allowed Amelia to breathe more easily. Although she knew plenty about the students and staff of Hogwarts, and even about some graduates, she didn’t often let on to how much she knew. She found that the longer she could remain anonymous, the more she could learn. People often believed themselves to be more discreet than they actually were, and Amelia had found that many of her fellow witches and wizards had a lot to hide, but didn’t do a very good job of it.
Although his original response to her words was somewhat positive, she was surprised to see his face change abruptly, an audible sigh passing his lips. Clearly his mind had gone elsewhere because he had the same reminiscent expression that she often got when her thoughts wandered away from the present situation. Whatever he was thinking about, it didn’t strike a harmonious chord.
His words were bitter as he looked up at her again, his eyes a little more empty than they had been just moments before. She wanted to ask him more about it, but couldn’t bring herself to pry. As a private, introverted person herself, she knew how unsettling it could be for someone to ask too many questions about the part of your life you intentionally kept hidden. Clearly Elijah had his own demons, but it wasn’t Amelia place to inquire about their form. Some small hint came from the fact that his fingers dwelled on his ring when he spoke, but without knowing more about the ring she could not fully understand what this observation could mean.
The emotion Elijah was feeling threaded its way through his next comment, although she doubted he intended to show it. She could hear the tension in his voice, the reluctant admission shedding light on a darker, more angry young man. Amelia’s lips turned down at the tone of his voice, sounding defeated in a way she would not have expected from a boy who looked as if he could exceedingly popular if he so chose.
She didn’t know how to deal with the emotions of others, mostly because she didn’t deal very well with her own. Rationality had won out over emotionality long ago and logic dominated the way she thought and acted so much so that it had also breached the walls of her heart, taking over where spontaneity and feeling out to reign supreme. Although she could sense that Elijah was distressed, she didn’t know how to deal with it, how to help, or even if she could.
“Nice is subjective,” Amelia replied softly, some part of her pushing to reveal something which would level the playing field between them, the other part throwing up barriers to stop this from happening, “The recipient of my letters may be nicer than yours, but I doubt very much the responses you get are more frustrating than those I receive.”
His letters are likely full disclosure. You can’t even get a scrap of information out of the person who used to be your best friend.