Marcus and Robert met at Khaat's office, and Robert opened the normally forbidden records locker.
"What are we looking for?" Robert asked.
"First, Suzanne," Marcus said.
"Why?" Robert frowned.
"Trust me," Marcus said. Robert opened the files, and they started to read. Robert was most curious when, during the summer before Suzanne was due to go to Hogwarts, after she had been accepted, she was taken to the hospital by her mother for an accident she suffered. The report said that Suzanne's mother said that she had been been playing in the potions cabinet in the bathroom, caused herself an accident, and her mother feared she had injured herself.
"That report doesn't say crap," Robert said, "but this is interesting. They said she was suffering from some sort of damage, and they believed, at that time, that it was emotional because she wasn't able to do any of the natural magic that she had been doing before she had the accident. That doesn't make any sense."
"Look here, though," Marcus said, handing him a report from her Hogwarts years. "She was brought in by the Hogwarts staff, and they had said that she couldn't cast a spell. Hogwarts had classified her as a squib! Her parents went bonkers apparently, and someone on staff at the hospital said she could do some very rudimentary magic spells. They believed it was the result of the emotional trauma she suffered as a child from the potions cabinet incident."
"Codswallop," Robert said. "Something is really fishy there." He pulled the files on Charlotte and began reading them. "Look here. Did you know that Charlotte never went to Hogwarts at all?"
"She didn't? Where'd she go, then?"
"Nowhere. She was determined at age 9 to be a squib herself. She never went to school beyond her elementary years."
"You're kidding."
"Nope," Robert said, handing the files to Marcus.
"Well, I'll be damned," Marcus said. "What about Pearl?"
"I don't know. Let's see, Oh, and I found Charlotte's husband's file--Gideon. Here." Robert fetched the files and opened Pearl's. "Pearll..."
"Robert, wait. Gideon Whitaker, died of suicide. Three years almost to the day before Charlotte died."
"Suicide? How?"
"Um...wait. I'll look for the autopsy..." Marcus searched the file. "He died of a self inflicted muggle gunshot wound, it says...Wait a minute. That's not even possible. Look here. The autopsy report shows the gunshot wound in the back of his head at the base of his skull. And on the left side of his head."
"Let me see that," Robert said. "This is an utter lie. Look here. Here's the giveaway. There's a notation of a callous on the second finger on his right hand. That's a writer's callous. Gabriel Florence was right handed. There's no possible way for him to shoot himself in the back of his own head, on the left hand side when he was right handed. This man was murdered."
"Exactly," Marcus said.
"What the hell have you stumbled onto?" Robert frowned at him.
"Maybe Pearl's file has some answers," Marcus said. The two of them finished reading the files, including Pearl's, and Robert loaded the whole batch of files up in his bag.
"You didn't see this," Robert said.
"See what?" Marcus said.
"Let's go home. Ruby and Jessie deserve to see this. I think this points us in a whole new direction."