Why don't you tell me what you want to hear, Sweetheart, and I'll fill in the blanks accordingly? he wanted to ask. No answer was right for her. No explanation was sufficient. He wasn't sure anything he could say would satisfy. How could it?
"Is that what you think? That it was easy? That I blissfully trotted off to parts unknown, waiving a Union Jack, whistling God Save the Queen, while I left you all behind? You don't think I once had a question? Ask your mother. The last couple of few months before I 'died,' I was gone late every single work night. I'm sure she was frustrated with all the 'overtime' she thought I was working. I was home with you every moment I could be, but in those evenings, what do you think I was doing? I was desperately searching out another way, anything. Any other idea. I was still looking for another way out, a way to turn it all around, when I left England.
"You know the problem with hindsight? Anyone who says its 20/20 is a liar. When we make a judgement call, all we have is what we know and what we feel and what we have the resources for at the time. When we look back on it in hindsight, all that has changed. Our knowledge is increased and therefore skewed. Our feelings certainly now are tainted, and our resources have been irrevocably changed. So, no. There's nothing accurate about hindsight.
"So we can spend years looking back at this in hindsight, and its never going to feel like what happened was right or fair. It wasn't. The people that got me into this are long dead. I'd love to expose them, haul them to the docks, and make them accountable, but in the end, it doesn't change anything for the Cooper family, does it?
"Did I think it was the right choice? No. Not for our family. I didn't want to think it was the right choice for England, but the Minister and his cronies kept telling me it not just the right choice but the only choice. And, they repeated to me over and over that if the mission did not happen, England would fall, and it would be completely my fault. At one point there was talk of tossing me in Azkaban for treason because I wasn't leaping onboard with all of this. I'm sure now that bit was just a lot of hot air. A strong arming tactic geared to frighten me into compliance. I made the only choice I believed I had." he said quietly, trying to hide his deep bitterness at being used and taken advantage of by the mentors he had trusted. "'Hell of a choice for a young man still in his 20's.
"The bottom line is that my leaving is never ever going to feel like it was the right choice for our family. No matter what explanation I can give. Its not going to feel like it was a right choice for us because, for us, it wasn't."
Lupin had mentioned to Rick that he wanted to right the wrongs of past Ministry administrations. Right now, though, Rick was questioning whether opening this all up again wasn't going to do more harm than good. Maybe Lupin was just like the others from his past. Maybe he was going to use him and his family one more time. Maybe Lupin had only wanted to tie up this old package rather nicely and tag Rick's name on it.
It was occurring to Rick, the more he listened to Hallie, that all Lupin had to do to accomplish just that was to bring Rick back and let him live openly. Then the Ministry was the hero, and Rick would go down in history as a vigilante outlaw in the likes of Wyatt Earp and all those others who took justice into their own hands. Maybe Lupin wasn't the honest man he was supposed to be. Maybe Rick was being just set up again. Rick just knew this wasn't the happy little family he had once had, and he wasn't feeling like he would get it back at this rate.
He ran his fingers through his hair, frustrated.
"Would you have understood me more if I had chosen Azkaban instead?" he asked her, looking at her. "Or would you have still hated me because you believed your father was a criminal? Hallie, I think just about every kid grows up thinking one of their parents is superhuman. That's actually normal childhood thinking. I am sorry you didn't have me long enough to live with me enough to go through the normal childhood frustrations with their parents so you could have learned for yourself I'm just a man. I'm not an angel, I'm not a demon. I'm just a man.
"I honestly never thought I'd have a chance to even see what you looked like, or hear what your voice sounded like. So this much, as tough as its been, has been more than I ever thought I'd have. I've missed you. And, lord, have I missed your mother...." His voice fell quiet. There had never, not even one time, been a thought of anyone else but Amelia, not a night he'd gone to bed without wishing she'd been beside him. When the grief had tried to consume him, it had always started with how much he missed Amelia and got deeper with thoughts of their children that he'd had to leave behind.