The worst nightmare that he had been trying to avoid was letting someone down. The last thing he’d wanted to do and the reason why he hadn’t was walk into a familial situation and find faces he didn’t know expecting to know him. He wasn’t that same person. He didn’t know who he was to Rose or Louis or Molly. He barely understood himself in relation to Fred who still refused to acknowledge that this James was different from the James he expected to walk through the door every day. He didn’t ignore the twinge of disappointment in Fred’s eyes, either. It hurt him, too. Every time his heart ached with sorrow, knowing that he wasn’t what Fred expected him to be. Then, this lady, this redhead who could’ve been family and who probably was near as dammit, he was letting her down, too. He just didn’t know. He looked upon her and he saw her peripheral features as ones he should’ve recognised but as he drew in, trying to capture her face with his gaze, it was as though the spell blocked him off and as though he couldn’t really see and understand her properly. He could only view her as a stranger, nothing more like he wanted to.
“I’m sorry,” James gasped pitifully, staring at the woman with large, saucer-shaped hazel eyes. The tears wanted to flood his cheeks but he was desperate not to let them. He didn’t think the old James cried. In fact, he was sure that the leather-wearing, motorcycle driving Quidditch player never cried. This new, bowtie-clad version had made it a reasonably often occurrence. It was often borne out of frustration but when he saw Fred, caught the man’s expression when he thought that James wasn’t looking, he wanted to scream with anguish and beat his fists upon the walls until his hands were red raw. Looking upon the redhead before him, he felt as though someone had launched their grasp into his chest and had torn his heart clean from inside. He knew that I wouldn’t be the last time, either, but he so desperately wanted to be the person she wanted him to be, the man she remembered. He didn’t want to hurt her in that way. Yet, he couldn’t help it. He wasn’t that man. He didn’t know if he could ever be.
“Albus,” James whispered, his lips coming together as he looked upon her. “You know my baby brother: you know Albus?”
Of course she did, something cynical in the back of his mind griped. She must’ve known him. If they’d been friends in school, she must’ve known Albus. It wasn’t until he’d sifted through his photographs that he realised just how strained and awkward the relationships between himself and his siblings were. There wasn’t a photograph of himself or Albus to be found after James’ seventh year and even then, they were on opposite sides of the line, grinning but with a handful of people betwixt them to keep them separate. The one he kept with him, as though from it he planned to draw some courage, was in his wallet, crinkled and faded now but it was one of James, Albus and their father. The boys were together, James’ arm around his neck. They were actually smiling. They looked happy to be with each other. But that, so the articles later informed him, was long before Harry had died. After that, the media coverage ensured that James wasn’t without some semblance of the way his life, and Albus’ had panned out. Not well, if his own case was indicative.
“I…” James buttoned his lips, unsure how to press on now he’d expressed an interest. “I …” James sighed again, his brows furrowing low over his eyes. Healer Macmillan had said that he’d find forming sentences difficult for a while. It’d been a year, nearly. For goodness sake. He almost wanted to slap himself or perhaps go and make another cup of tea and eat a sandwich – or ten. Then maybe he’d hide behind the workbench and bury his face in his hands and ignore Thomas, regardless of the man’s insistence that James talk to him. He’d want to know. He’d been there. He’d tried to get in. He’d tried. He’d tried with this James. More than anyone else he seemed to understand. Even the Healers looked at him like he was a ticking explosive, on self-destruct mode with no timer to give fair warning when he was going to explode. Fred didn’t believe him. This redhead… this lady. His friend. His friend, she wanted him to be that. She wanted him to be who she remembered and Merlin, he wanted too.
“How is he?” James asked quietly, finding his words. “Is he alright? Is he… does he need …” James closed his eyes. Me, he wanted to say, does he need me?
He couldn’t remember the happier times. Had he been able to, perhaps he wouldn’t have felt so awful about it. He could’ve feigned, or rather, genuinely possessed, ignorance and eagerly could have taken up the gauntlet from where he believed them to have been at their best: when James was six, just before Harry died. But it had all changed, hadn’t it? James knew, he just knew, that Albus didn’t like him. It made sense, didn’t it, after everything that he’d read? Maybe he didn’t, but James highly doubted it. He knew that he probably didn’t like Albus very much, either, before everything had gone wrong. But how could he be sure when he didn’t even know his own name waking up for the first time? How could he be sure that his baby brother was safe and warm somewhere with someone to love him and everything settled and right? He couldn’t be. Just like he had no idea where Lily was. Lily Luna, the other anomaly he knew he cared so much about but couldn’t face. Was she safe and warm … did someone love her? But what of him? James had been safe and warm from the get-go but he didn’t know if there was anyone, apart from maybe his attention-to-detail, James-needs-sesame-seed-toast-or-he’ll-kill boss who understood him as he was now, who loved him. Red, Fred… they loved the old him, misguided though it was. Misguided though he was.
James collapsed back into a chair and he took off his glasses. Catching the handle between his teeth, he rubbed his hands across his face, smoothing the escapee tears into his skin. He sighed loudly, heavily and hardly. He didn’t know what to do. Whether Albus needed him or not and whether Lily did, too, was irrelevant. If it was all as poor as he’d been told then they didn’t need him. Not old him and probably not the new version of himself either who was, in two pairs of eyes, viewed now as lesser and strange, alien, and not… not James. This person beside him, this friend, needed him. For some reason she needed him.
“I… want to try to understand, alright?” James asked, thoroughly finished with this whole debacle. He rubbed his hand across the hair on his cheek and brought his fingers round to pull at the hair on his chin absentmindedly. He looked at her out from under his long eyelashes and dropped his gaze immediately, shame sending him into a metaphorical puddle on the cold stone floor.
James laughed a bit despite himself all of a sudden as he brought his hand round to tug at the back of his neck. He shook himself and lifted his eyes up once more to look at the redhead as a wry smile lifted across his features.
“Do you want to know a secret?” He asked as he picked a bit of stray lint off of his trousers. “I’m actually terrified of heights. But I, uh, I still have the bike.” James sat back in the chair, sticking his legs out and folding his ankles over one another. He then crossed his arms over his chest and tipped his head back, letting his eyes close as he braced his head against the wall.
“Sirius is my dad’s godfather, yeah? My granddad’s best friend. One of the Marauders.” He cocked an eye open as a sly, almost-Jamesian smile swept over his lips. “I’ve done my reading, believe you and me. I spent hours sifting through that flat, trying to get something – anything – in my head about me and everyone else. Nothin’, though, it was all for nothin’. Here I am, none the wiser and the bits I can get to grips with … they’re fuzzy and none of it feels like it’s me, y’know? So, that useless fact for you there is …yeah, useless.”
James sighed, his frustration bleeding through into cynicism. He shook himself a little, trying to get some optimism flowing through his veins again.
“So, Jamie’s… a friend too or?” James glanced over at her again. “Sad story I probably don’t want to know about, yeah?” He inquired, that wry smile returning once more. He chuckled a little, albeit humourlessly, and resumed his former position.
“I’m James, by the way,” he interjected finally. “And you, being one of my best mates are … you have a name, surely? Or did I call you ‘Red’? I mean, that’s fine. That’s … that can be a thing but I guess, names are better, huh? Because I feel like … I’m not, look… oh, Merlin. I don’t reckon I’m going to remember you or anyone else sharpish so what I’ve been trying to do not very successfully with Fred is be… me and for him to be friends with me as me and not… old me.” James sighed, realising how ridiculous he sounded. “Can we backtrack and start again, d’you think? Maybe you could tell me some more things?”