Amelia was beginning to wonder how much more of this smiling she could take from Peter, who seemed to have just that one reaction, no matter what set of stimuli he was presented with. It was hard not to want to shake him and ask him what was making him happy enough to grin ear to ear on what seemed like no more than a seven-second time delay, but Amelia knew this would be breaking many social rules, and thus kept her hands to herself. She even managed a smirk when Peter’s response to her question turned out to be as snide and sarcastic as a few of hers had been earlier in the conversation.
It wasn’t everyone that could give Amelia a taste of her own medicine, or would even bother to. Usually, when she treated people poorly in order to get rid of them quickly, her goals were easily achieved; no one took her barrage of sharp-tongued comments and cold shoulder responses for too long. But Peter, it seemed, had a thicker skin and about as many comebacks in his arsenal as she did, which was throwing Amelia slightly off her game.
When he pulled the broom down from his shoulder, Amelia took an unconscious step back, as though the bit of wood and twigs might suddenly turn into a serpent hell bent on sinking its teeth through her flesh. Obviously, she knew this would not be the case, but the broom was such a foreign object to her that she did not know what to do with it being so close to her. When Peter continued his response, less sarcastically this time, Amelia was not at all, how did they say it, “drinking the Kool-Aid”? She was much more firmly in the camp of the people who didn’t like being up so high, and the thought of it actually made her visually cringe.
When he compared the feeling to running, however, Amelia momentarily found herself identifying with what Peter was saying. Freedom was one of the reasons she ran, and she did love the feeling of leaving everything behind her, being in her own mind and in control of her own world. This identification was enough even for Amelia to offer Peter a half-smile when she found him grinning back at her once more, the urge to shake him not quite as great this time.
The boy was looking fondly at his broomstick – obviously the snake idea had not occurred to him – and when he turned his eyes back on her, he had a question to go with his eye contact. Although she had hesitated to answer some of the previous questions, this one was easily answered, and Amelia’s response was quick and rather louder than she might have intended.
“Oh heavens no,” Amelia said, shaking her head vigorously and raising her hands in front of her with her palms facing Peter, in case her words alone would not have been enough, “No, no. I like my feet firmly on the ground, thank you very much.”
“It is a required course for all Hogwarts students,” she continued, letting her hands fall back to their normal positions, “flying, that is. But my mother had her own opinion on the usefulness and ladylike nature of flying around on an oversized twig, so I got to take Arithmancy instead.”
This was probably the only bit of personal information she had shared with someone in a long time, and it did not go unnoticed by Amelia. She could easily have stopped after the first sentence of her answer, for it would have provided sufficient information, but instead she had continued. She was not sure what had tricked her into doing so – and yes, Amelia fully did believe it was a trick – but she had a feeling it had something to do with Peter’s incessant smiling.
“H-how long have you been flying?” Amelia stuttered, still a bit thrown by her own uncharacteristic display of being forthcoming with personal information. She had to get the question out, though, in the hopes that she could turn the conversation back around on Peter and let him be the focus for the rest of their chat, however long that lasted. It had already gone on longer than she had initially anticipated, which was yet another thing she could not explain, and without a firm grip on what was causing the conversation to extend itself, Amelia couldn’t really predict how long it might continue.