Re: New Poll

by Guest Tue Mar 09, 2010 9:57 pm

Yeah, a lot was left unclear but that was sort of the joy of it. Make it whatever you want. I don't know. I liked it.

by **Jemma Tiquelle** Tue Mar 09, 2010 10:03 pm

Apart from nothing about the veil ever being explained EVER then it was good. I think some deaths were necessary. Remus and Tonks RIP Sad

.

by Guest Tue Mar 09, 2010 10:23 pm

Agreed. It would be too lovey-dovey if she did not kill off at least a FEW loved chracters. It is unrealistic that no one we like would die and all of the bad guys would. That is just not how it is in real life..

by Guest Thu Mar 11, 2010 3:44 am

Lysander Scamander wrote:Yeah, a lot was left unclear but that was sort of the joy of it. Make it whatever you want. I don't know. I liked it.

You can just google an HP characters name then put "harry potter wiki" after it and it should shoul up HP style Very Happy

I've done that many times, like harry came on to be head of the Aurors department (but not on Potters Army of course)

by **Christabelle Whittle** Thu Mar 11, 2010 3:58 am

I think the epilouge in the end of the books was complete crap in my opinion and I agree with Jemma about the veil being explained but I like to think of it as the veil between the spirit world and our world since it was in the department of mysteries. But I would definately re-write the epilouge in the final book.

by Gackt Kazama Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:53 pm

i wouldnt have killed off the twin, i would have killed off draco malfoy though , kept snape alive. and for dramatic effect and because i think she is the weakest character in the books ginny, besides that would have made it more tragic. and i would have re-written the epilogue as well. hermione should have a least been the minister of magic, i would have made ron a pro qudditch player for the chuddley cannons.

by Guest Sat Mar 13, 2010 1:04 am

In my opinion, the book would be well...too good if that was the outcome. I probably woulda thrown the book into a river and shun myself from Harry Potter....But still......I'd like Snape being alive Very Happy

rules	plot
application	guide
canon list	ic news
claims	casting call
rp request	help

IF you were responsible for writing the ending for the Potter books, would you have made the same choices for the characters' endings?