Re: Rate the site!

by Jack Uhler Wed Dec 16, 2009 11:14 pm

10/10

forumation is wrong its 10/10 Razz

what happened to the website that all the RP sites were rated on?

by **Darren** Thu Dec 17, 2009 2:22 am

Allura Draig wrote:5/10

Several of the site rules aren't being enforced. Sometimes the people ignoring them are actually mods and admins. One of the reasons I joined this site is because it had a good set of rules. Reasonable and not over the top. But you have to obey and enforce them or some of the members will take advantage at the expense of other members' enjoyment of the site.

Because this site has some variations from canon, it would be nice if those variations were explained clearly and everyone was held to it. Like, these are the rules for all vampires, and these are the rules for all werewolves and these are the rules for all veela. Or perhaps rules is the wrong word. An outline of traits, is more what I mean.

On every application I've seen, people have trouble with the year. How hard is it to put the current year in the timeline thread?

There are spelling and grammar mistakes all through the information sections.

Its OK Ne'os, critisicms good, then we can improve the site.

What rules exactly? I can't go through every thread checking that people aren't following the rules, members have to tell us. If we see that they aren't, we'll talk with that member, but otherwise.

As for the year.. I didn't update the timeline for a while. So thats true, but if a member wants to join, then he should read the plot, and the plot has the current year. If he or shedoesn't bother reading the plot, then he wouldn't know the current year. Its hardly my fault they can't be bothered reading the plot.

by Scorpius Malfoy 1 Thu Dec 17, 2009 2:49 am

I agree with the typos, it wouldn't be to hard to change that. But 5/10 is waaaaaaaaaaaay to harsh.

by Guest Thu Dec 17, 2009 3:52 am

Darren, I think it's really cute that you went and updated your post right after I criticised it (seriously, it makes me feel like I'm doing some good). It think it's even more cute that you got the year wrong. If Scorpius and Albus are in sixth year, it should be 2023.

For the record, I started at ten and deducted one "mark" for every thing that I found wrong. You might think 5 is harsh, but I think 10 is generous. I've just been on sites that are better organised. They're also usually more controlling and have little cliques on them and half the time the administrators will PM you to tell you you're playing your character wrong, as if they know more about your character than you do. No site is perfect and I would never give any site a perfect score.

by **Darren** Thu Dec 17, 2009 4:15 am

The year was always in the subplots, I didn't edit that right now.

And I think you have the year wrong tbh
DH ended in sep 1 2017, with Albus and Scorpius in 1st year.
so it would go
sep 2018 year 2
sep 2019 year 3
sep 2020 grade 4
sep 2021 grade 5
sep 2022 grade 6

Though I wouldn't rate the site too highly myself, I know it has faults, all sites do, so a 10 is unrealistic. So a 7.5 isnt exactly bad, though I saw the review and he took points off wrong stuff...

by Kingsley Shacklebolt Wed Dec 23, 2009 4:53 am

I changed my mind

7.5 was an exaggeration.

1/10

by Raphael Stravos Valentine Wed Dec 23, 2009 5:25 am

rules	plot
application	guide
canon list	ic news
claims	casting call
rp request	help