Rosiers never gave into intimidation. This much Phaedra knew was true. But they did, apparently, give into something else- something she rather optimistically deemed discomfort. The more he stalked towards her the more she felt like she needed to step away and she couldn’t for the life of her explain why. There was a danger she sensed in being too close to him and it wasn’t from fear. She wasn’t scared. But she couldn’t tell what she was.
In any case, as he got close enough to tilt her head back, she stepped back, only enough to put a respectable amount of distance between them because she absolutely couldn’t stand in such close proximity to him any longer. One small step. But the desk was still behind her, and short of sitting on it, there wasn’t anything she could do. So she stood up straighter, refusing the slouch that could be mistaken for a cower. She had to draw the line somewhere.
She knew she should offer a meaningless apology or a bland platitude to cool the air between them and return them to the uneasy, frosty politeness they’d somewhat reluctantly settled into. She knew she should stop pushing, just let it be and hope he didn’t decide to throw her out and rescind his offer. But his domineering, sanctimonious manner infuriated her and she couldn’t stop. For the first time in a long while, the words left of their own volition, against all her better impulses.
“Spoken like a true Rookwood. I’m sure your father would be proud. A couple of Unforgiveables here, a harsh word there- impressive, no doubt.” It came out sharper than she’d actually intended. A low blow, yes, but between the two of them it seemed nothing was too far below the belt. Though she didn’t doubt both had much worse to give, if pushed even further. His dark, harsh gaze bore into her. She was no longer flushed, but felt like the blood had drained out of her. She was sure any colour she’d gained from her Mediterranean stay was now blanched. Even her lips, red though they appeared, felt numb. A horrible cold feeling had settled over her and infused her tone with sharp, brittle ice. Every part of her was stiff- only her heart was racing. Was that fear?
“Clearly, you know far less than you’d like to imagine, Hayes Jr.” A cruel sort of smirk curled her lips- completely lacking any amusement, startlingly unbecoming on such fine features. If he was asking about wards and poisons then evidently his knowledge stopped short of the last 4 years, much like everyone else’s. And the time before that no longer belonged to her but to her younger, happier self, the one she’d long since stopped trying to recover. Really, he knew no more about the woman who stood before him than she still knew about herself.
But, since they were on the topic of Death Eaters, she could tell him about her great-grandfather, one of the first. Her grand-father, who’d been raised and died by their creed. Her uncles, who’d aligned themselves with the cause and yet escaped the humiliation of Azkaban- something that couldn’t be said for the Rookwoods. Her second cousin, who’d been Voldemort’s favourite general- and something more, if rumours were to be believed. Even her grandmother, whose love for poisons extended beyond the intellectual into the extremely practical.
Or better yet, the Medicis, who’d achieved infamy among the non-magical as well as the magical, feared and respected in equal measure over the centuries. Whose views and behaviour even she couldn’t stomach so easily. But Phaedra wasn’t actually interested in that, at all. She had no desire to partake in a pissing contest with a Hayes, of all people. She had nothing to prove.
“You think because you managed to figure out my name that tells you anything about me?”
Or maybe she did. Her scoff was far quieter than his, might even have been called a snort if she actually did such a thing. Derisive, yes, but lacking the force of her earlier words. Because really, though she’d never in a million years admit it, the only thing Phaedra wanted to do at that moment was sink into the chair and put her head in her hands. How on earth had she managed to get herself into this position? She was almost glad that Keiran was close enough to block any opportunity to run, because if there was one thing she couldn’t do after all he’d said it was to appear in any way shaken or anything less than entirely self-possessed. Cold, haughty, and unaffected. A challenge, once she’d decided on giving him the explanation he so badly wanted and voicing some of the words she’d held close to her chest for years, still reeling from the shock behind them. It was hard to force them out. She closed her eyes for the barest moment, pressing her lips firmly together and inhaling deeply. When they opened, they held none of their earlier fire. Just that awful empty chill.
“My father died 4 years ago. He was one of the first to be infected with the Green Itch. We thought it was Dragon Pox, at first, we never could have…He had the best care. We didn’t see it coming. Not quite a murder, but wholly unexpected. It took my mother 2 years to recover and my b-…” A pause. Another breath. “No father, no heir- the Rookwoods can tell you what that means. We left. In the middle of the night, under cover of darkness. Like thieves. Four years in self-imposed exile, because what else can wives and daughters do? ” A heavy, heavy bitterness laced those last sentences, burying her disbelief at speaking any of this aloud in the first place. "My mother didn't come back. There is nothing here for her to return to.”
She said the last bit as an afterthought, feeling that it would add to the explanation. But she wasn’t sure if she was talking about Elisavetta or herself. It came out quieter, a little harder, even as she tried to keep her tone carefully modulated.
Talking about her mother was easier than talking about herself. Elisavetta’s choice was clear, she felt none of the pull her daughter felt to their old home. No demons haunted her on the Amalfi coast. But then, she wasn’t a Rosier. She’d taken the name in law, but she was a Medici. She always had been. In this hardship, that had become clear to Phaedra. Her mother’s time in England was over, but the Rosier land was her birthright. But how could she even begin to explain that to the man in front of her, a stranger- Rookwood though he apparently was- to her world and to her life? How to even start on the situation with her uncle, which she still didn't understand? Where would she begin?
“My family suffered more than most. We lost everything. And the only way to have the barest hope of regaining it all is by cracking some wards- our own, not yours. So, I hate to destroy the image you’d rather maintain of me as a murderess or whatever hare-brained accusation you’d like to throw at me next, but I’m well-acquainted with loss. I didn't cause your own. Is that sufficient enough for you?”
Every word was stiff, clipped, the question icy. She neglected to mention Caspian, unable to brush against the wound that was the rawest of them all. And tempted as she was to focus her attention on his chin, or his chest, or a spot on the wall behind him, she kept her eyes trained on his, hard and unrelenting, pain buried beneath the traces of silent wrath. Because despite the show of strength, she’d found herself strangely reluctant to meet Keiran’s gaze as she revealed her own loss. She’d hardly been gracious about his- and she certainly didn’t expect his sympathy- but there was something uncomfortable about being flippant in the face of others’ grief then revealing it to be a shared experience.
But she wasn’t giving him the information in hopes of getting into his good graces. She couldn’t give a flying fig what he thought of her, now or before. And after his words she no longer even wanted either book anymore, no longer wanted to ever set foot in that library again. It felt too much like charity, now. In a strange way, she felt like she had something to prove. While- short of veritaserum- she couldn’t see how he planned to ascertain if she was telling the truth, she also couldn’t see any tangible benefit in lying. And there was something undignified about an unconvincing lie. Something that made you look more desperate than you already were.
“I was hesitant to share it with you because you’d never understand, for all your immense genius and influence. I’ll take your word that you’re generally a good man. Dangerous, even. Grieving, evidently. But I hardly think you’re qualified to comment on anything other than the happy image of domesticity. Forgive my assumptions,” -no more a real request than the one she echoed- “but what could you possibly understand about me? What on earth would you know about a life collapsing in on itself?”
No, it hadn’t escaped her notice that he evidently had kids he cared for, and a whole litany of female names, one of whom was undoubtedly a significant other of some sort. Men like Keiran Hayes had happy families and rather placid lives, reveling in the daily drudgery of domestic existence. There was a sort of bliss to be found in such an existence. It was one she’d taken for granted lay in her future, would have been living right now had the Green Itch not taken all that away from her. It wasn’t that Phaedra had a strong preference either way- marriage and babies was what was expected of her, and she was happy to go along- but to have your plans go so completely awry and then be lectured so self-righteously by someone whose life was evidently going swimmingly overall was too much to bear.
Aiden came to mind but she dismissed the thought, refusing to have any qualms about what she’d already said. Losing a father did not constitute the world as you knew it collapsing around you, no matter how tragic the circumstances. No, she was referring to the sickening helplessness of being so totally, completely mired in loss that even turning back was no longer an option. The awful realisation that your life had been irrevocably exchanged for something you’d never wanted through no fault of your own. Another person taking everything you valued and placing it so far out of reach that it seemed sure you’d never be happy again.
She'd deflated with her explanation, tiredness and frustration taking their toll, leaning back into the desk unconsciously. But now she stepped forward again, not noticing or perhaps ignoring the way it felt less like she was attempting defiance and more like she was drawn towards the possibility of being proved wrong. Even then, she lifted her chin obstinately, refusing to concede any weakness that she could control, ignoring the charged air between them, the intensity that was strangely draining, now.
“So go ahead and do your worst,” her gaze flickered meaningfully to the hand that rested on his wand, loaded with scorn. She made no attempt to reach for her own. She trusted- ironically enough- that he wouldn't actually draw his wand on her. The words came quietly, tone low, free of the earlier venom though heavy with the same bitterness. “But save your judgements. I can make my own.”
For all his talk about underestimation, she was sure that nothing he’d done could come close to what she feared she’d managed. Because that’s what it all came down to. He was half Rookwood, sure. But her blood carried the full toxicity of two formidable bloodlines. There was no part of her that hadn’t been steeped in darkness. Even when she’d tried to escape it and do something good for once, to step into the light if only temporarily, she’d ended up being lethal anyway. Was that what he’d recognised in her?
In that moment she knew. For all her bluster and offence, her contempt at his insistence on dredging up the past, on shoving her demons into her face, the defensiveness he triggered in her, his own professed willingness to demonstrate just how far he was willing to go, the strange intensity between them– she wasn’t afraid of Keiran Hayes.
She could never be as afraid of him as she was of herself.