Oliver didn't know whether he found their refusal to accept odd circumstances charming or odd. To be fair, he would have been worried if it were Alice, too, so he definitely couldn't blame James for panicking a bit. The fact that he had Esme with him just reminded Oliver of his other roommate, Ariel, and it made him realize very quickly that he wasn't going to be able to say no to them. Some part of his mind immediately wondered what Alice was up to, but he didn't doubt that his father would have said something if Alice hadn't shown up at work.
The only difference, he reminded himself, was that he and Alice were practically married at that point, even if nothing had actually been done yet to make it that way. How well did James know this woman he was seeing? Perhaps it was all a misunderstanding, and Oliver would find her very quickly.
Letting out a sigh, Oliver nodded - a silent agreement to help them. Of course, it didn't even register with him that the woman had the same last name as the one who had ruined everything for the Order. Ironically, however, the first question he asked was,
"Does she have any family around here? I don't know how close she is to them, of course, but perhaps they would know what happened or have a suggestion for where to look." Lifting a shoulder, he added, "Can you describe her at all? I can't tell if I saw her while the Order was here to help on Friday."
[ooc: I'm going off of the assumption that, at her parents' house in Florida, they finally caved and told Hadley about Audriana, and that's how she got in touch with them. Also, on the idea I suggested about Hadley mentioning it to Esme a couple days before.]