Oliver didn't mean to, but he found himself frustrated once again as Paul explained. If Alice had been as young as everyone claimed, why had Elijah been so set on her? And how did they know, anyway? He of course chose not to voice those questions, as they would only come out as petulant and possessive. To be fair, those adjectives would make sense, given his train of thought. But he didn't need Paul to know that, did he?
So, instead, he took in all of the information that he was offered about his Deputy Minister, rathet blissfully unaware of the meeting that would occur later that week with the Hayes, an ex-Hayes, and Krum himself. When the conversation turned back to Alice, Oliver's face fell into a dark and, this time visibly, possessive frown.
"She did, yes," he replied, nodding. Oliver looked down at the cup Paul had made him, turning it a bit between his hands. "She told me to ask for a... a box. She said you would know which," he added, glancing up. His frown had been replaced with an oddly (for him, anyway, as of late) vulnerable expression. "Sir, I- ...I don't know how to protect her if I don't even understand why they went after her like that." Oliver couldn't bring himself to use the work 'kill' in relation to Alice, but he was trying to get his point across as best as he could. "What is it that she knew, or- or saw? If Alice herself doesn't know, then- I don't see what Krum would expect. I can obviously swear to you that I'll sooner hex him than let him do anything to her. But what if he knows things we don't? Maybe it would be better to tell him, ourselves. If we get the chance, that is."
Shaking his head, Oliver looked down again. "I'm tired of making mistakes when it comes to her. I don't really even want to look through the box, because it feels like I'm prying or showing her that I don't trust that she has told me the truth. But I also can't protect her if I don't have all of the pieces of the puzzle, so I suppose I have to." He transferred his cup to his right hand, running his dominant one through his hair before lifting his chin once more.
"I want to be the sort of man that she deserves, but I never seem to get it quite right. In truth, I came here to warn you about Krum and to ask about the box, but there's also something else. I didn't want to get it wrong this time, and perhaps I should have been brave enough to not ask her, as it's hardly the traditional way to go about it, but I did. I needed to know that she wanted the future I was offering before speaking to you about it. But... Unless this ordeal with Krum goes sour and she changes her mind, I'd like to think she really is okay with it all. Which is why," his speech slowed as he wondered whether or not Paul already had him figured out, "I want to ask you this now, before anything else crazy happens. I know that now isn't the time to do it, but... When I do find a time where I think she feels safe enough to make the choice that's best for her, would you be supportive of my asking her to marry me?
"She loves you more than anybody," he went on more rapidly, "and you just accepting it wouldn't be enough for me to feel right about it. I would understand, I guess, if it was just that, or even less than that. But it doesn't mean I wouldn't show up at your door down the road to ask you again, after I've proven myself more fully."