If there was one thing Oliver wanted, it was to just shut everyone up. The language being used was unacceptable for starters, but he also had to listen to people bickering over what to do now that Augustus had been brought in. He had expected them to be happier that he kept the Death Eater where they could see them, rather than letting him go, but apparently that was not the case. When had a call to a meeting ever turned so rapidly into death threats and a visible divide between members? Oliver couldn't remember the last time that had happened, but he also couldn't claim to have been around as long as some of the others.
"You," Oliver turned on Rookwood, pointing a finger at him, "Shut it." Then, far less abrasively, to Jack, "If he keeps it up, we may have to."
Of course, James had a plan that Oliver actually didn't dislike for once, and the author looked up in muted surprise. "Not a bad idea," he put in, shooting another warning glance in the Death Eater's direction. "Right now, it seems like the only one of you worth keeping around after this meeting is most definitely Potter. Until we actually need you, it would be wise to keep your mouth shut. Then I might not change my mind when we're done here."
To say he was astounded by Selwyn's violent reaction would have been a slight understatement. Mostly, Oliver just wondered if something had happened between them in the past. Yes, Oliver was furious for what happened to Alice. But he knew better than to get rid of their only direct connection to the Death Eaters. They had Ben and Theo, but those two could only risk so much without getting caught. Oliver wasn't about to risk that. Even if it felt strange to say that he would risk this other man's life in place of theirs, it was the unfortunate truth.
"Alright!" he said finally, his voice louder than he actually intended it to be. "Everybody needs to just calm down. Don't you see what a problem this is? Nobody will stop long enough to realize we're all on the same side! So just sit down and listen."
He watched as a few people reluctantly followed suit, and in the space between his outburst and the next thing he said, Oliver moved to Alice's side, holding out a hand. She had just been attacked, and he wasn't about to force any contact on her, especially when he still didn't understand. Offering a grateful smile when she took it, he led her over to one of the chairs and let her take it, standing at one side.
"Answer me this. Which is a bigger number?” Oliver asked seriously, looking around the room. “One? Or three?”
He paused for a moment, taking in the confused and perhaps slightly annoyed expressions of those who met his gaze. Finally, Tobias rolled his eyes and put out, “three,” almost sarcastically.
“Three.” Oliver repeated. He nodded, lifting his arm to set it on the back of Alice's chair, then turned to look at everyone again. “No. Not three. One. One group – one faction – together against the Ministry, the Death Eaters, and anyone else working against us. It’s not about winning anything or defeating anyone. It’s about protecting the ideals we know are right and ensuring the safety of those who can’t do so for themselves. One collective bunch, all deciding to just shut up for once and do something instead of arguing over how many people are going, or how badly someone might ruin their clothes, or whatever else,” he went on, clearly unimpressed with the typical happenings at their meetings.
“This group was founded to take action. To do things where others were afraid or when nobody else could. If you aren’t interested in that, you can leave. I, for one, am tired of just reading about people who choose to be heroes. Or hearing about them, or watching them, or whatever else. I want to be one of them. I refuse to be a so-called leader and then sit around while others fight. And you can choose for yourselves whether or not you want to be a hero, too. If that doesn’t suit you, get out now. Go home and wait for someone else to do the dirty work. Just know that, whoever is around to do it, I’ll be in the battles with you.
"Until then, however," Oliver continued, looking at each person in turn, "I need to have people who are willing to discuss things rather than fight about them. So how about we come up with something that will help us defend ourselves and will help us be more prepared, hmm? I don't think we'll want Rookwood in the room when we decide on those things, though. So," he concluded reluctantly, "Jack might be right. IF you all can agree to act like adults, we'll need a way to ensure he won't be able to run back and tell anyone about it. Suggestions?" he asked, turning to her.