Alisha Merchant had a theory.
Had. Past tense.
Now, she pretty much had a confirmation and a growing itch in her palms to just confront the truth already. Which she already knew. Which is what confirmation of theory means.
.
It began as a niggling suspicion, one that Alisha had no doubt most of their ever expanding circle of friends had entertained at one point or the other, with the possible exception of His Highness, The Royal Duck; because he was remarkably obtuse like that. Okay, Alisha wouldn’t exactly call herself the spawn of Sherlock Holmes or whatever, but she did have some observational skills. Like, she could totally predict breakups before they happened. Maybe because she’d snogged the guy in question the previous night…..but yeah, whatever, hand wavy motions, details.
Point being? Fiona Grimm, Finn dearest, the one whose sad eyes and furrowed forehead could probably launch a thousand ships (okay, more like the collective ire of the entire gang if someone dared raise an eyebrow at her); just like one of those pallid, paper-complexioned, teenage girl version of puppies whom you just had to protect against anything and everything in the world, including but not limited to Dark wizards, tornadoes, other teenage girls and Crumple Horned Snorkacks. Yeah, her. She was hiding something. The sentence was admittedly a little redundant, seeing how her dorm mate sometimes liked to float from room to room hiding her existence from all other occupants- but she was definitely hiding something more. Something major.
Facts supporting this conclusion:
A) Finn was not a good liar. Yeah, okay, maybe Alisha wasn’t the best judge considering the fact that she, y’know, sort of couldn’t lie at all, pretty much literally- but that didn’t mean she wasn’t skilled at obfuscation. She knew how to lie without lying. Knew how to phrase things so that they’d juuuuust straddle the line of truth. But Finn, in spite of being rather unhampered by highly inconvenient Unbreakable Vows (which Ali couldn’t be completely sure about, but it was highly unlikely two girls with the same problem would end up attending the same school, same age, same House, same bloody dorm. Ali had studied probability in Spain.), was a rather crappy liar, as far as she could tell. She’d stammer or stutter or look in the other direction or up above at the sky or at her highly interesting shoelaces- and all those were Tells. Considering that Finn tended to exhibit all these symptoms every time one of her ‘weekend trips’ came up? Yeah. Something fishy was definitely going on here.
B) The ‘weekend trips’. Alisha had a great-great aunt Shalini, who puked when she ate rice and puked when she ate bread, hurled when she had pumpkin pies and hurled when she had pumpkin juice, who detested vegan food and couldn’t keep down meat or cellulose, and for the past twenty years had been seen in reunions only sipping a dark green viscous fluid, probably from the same glass. (There were wagers as to what that mysterious drink was. Alisha’s bet was on bone marrow and grass extract.) Basically….it all amounted to the fact that Alisha knew sick people and rotten constitutions. Sure, Finn got queasy with normal food now and then, picked at her plate like a sparrow, looked deadly pale most of the time, but that was just Finn for you. Alisha never got any indication during the days preceding the trips that Finn was feeling remarkably under the weather or anything. Add to that the fact that Hogwarts was a great old dirty castle right in the middle of nowhere, but could be reasonably called the Scottish countryside if you were inclined to be finicky, and the whole excuse of Finn departing from school to get some ‘countryside air’ fell through like rotten wood. What, did they manufacture different flavours of countryside air now?
C) Finn never returned looking particularly rejuvenated, just the same old ‘please please don’t look at me’ Finn expression that she’d been sporting for over five years now. Sometimes she even looked wearier. That did not look like a girl taking weekend trips to restore her health or see brilliant places.
D) Alisha had had the history of the Second Wizarding War read out to her a million times by now. Her favourite part was about the Marauders.
Alisha Merchant didn’t jump to conclusions. She compiled all her facts, wrote them down behind her Transfig homework with a borrowed pen in a list, and deduced the obvious. Which, honestly, was so damn obvious that she felt like hitting everyone else around her upside the head simply for not seeing it. Honestly, was she the only person with a brain around here? There could be no other possible conclusion.
Fiona Grimm was a werewolf.
(Ali didn’t think about checking if Finn had bruises from her obviously horrible transformations. Or about checking the moon charts to see if Finn’s departures coincided with full moon nights. Or even think about the fact that sometimes Finn disappeared twice a month, which is a bit of an impossible feat for full moons. No, Alisha Merchant’s head worked in very clean, logical, straight lines. Sickly complexion + Mysterious disappearances = werewolf)
Alisha wasn’t hurt. Much. She could understand why Finn had deemed it necessary to hide it from them, what with all the anti-werewolf legislation in the wake of James Blood in the past year. She was just a teeny-weeny bit wounded about the fact that Finn would think that Alisha would judge her. Honestly, like it wasn’t the coolest thing ever that tiny, timid little Finn transformed into a throat-ripping beast once a month. Alisha didn’t even get a chance to step forward and declaim how nothing could get in the way of their friendship, and of course she wouldn’t look at Finn differently, and she didn’t even have to ask Ali about becoming a fierce, gorgeous tiger Animagus in order to help her out and drag all their friends into doing the same and becoming school legends and everything.
Or a lion Animagus. Or a reindeer. Alisha wasn’t picky.
So she waited patiently on Finn to come and confess the truth to them, weekend after weekend, waited to make her own ever loyal, emotionally stirring declaration. It was hard. Alisha wasn’t accustomed to waiting for anything beyond pushing the button on the coffee machine at home, and coffee gushing out of the nozzle. But then summer came and Finn never said anything, which totally stunned Alisha, even though summer had come five times since their time at Hogwarts and everything and Finn had never said a word before. But yes. Alisha was stunned and surprised and a little indignant and compelled to wait for a week at Hogwarts all alone while her parents made the trip from Java to Scotland all alone and highly bored and kind of itching to have an Adventure.
So she followed Finn home.
Okay, she’d have totally loved to don a trench coat and fedora and hide behind garbage bins as Finn made her way through the streets of Boston homewards or whatever- probably humming the title track of Pink Panther under her breath. But the summer temperatures were sweltering, and Alisha had to content her artistic sensibilities with shorts and a sleeveless tee. Portkeys were a little tricky to shadow too, so she solved that by planting a Tracking Charm on the little bead she snuck into Finn’s pocket during the goodbye-see-you-next-fall hug. (It was a very one-sided hug. Alisha was a generous soul though, so she didn’t add that to her list of grievances against the Grimm).
So the morning after the night Finn departed, standing outside the gates of Hoggy-Warty-Hogwarts, Ali clicked the heels of her sneakers against each other and spoke the magic word. A few indeterminable seconds of Determination, Deliberation, Destination something something later, she opened her eyes to see…..huh. Another filthy big castle.
Seemed to be the same size as her ancestral home too, and damn wouldn’t Daadi be annoyed to hear that, the arrogant codger that she was.
Ooh, there was Finn. And a cat.
“Hi Finn!” She waved, with both hands batting side to side. “And cat. Nice crown!”