Ben stood amongst the other first years waiting to be sorted, hands clenched and shivering from the cold. The Great Hall itself was warm and absolutely awe inspiring. Ben couldn’t remember if he had ever been in such a grand room. Hogwarts was the most beautiful sight he had ever seen. In most other circumstances, he would be absolutely thrilled at such a place. This was not most other circumstances. Ben felt an almost devastating chill run through him that had little to do with the temperature. His first Hogwarts experience was in fact, the most terrifying of his entire life. He was not of a magical family and still, at this moment, did not fully understand what had happened or what was even happening now.
It was all a confusing distortion to Ben and for the first time since he had found out he was a wizard, Ben wanted to go home. He had seen people die tonight… bodies floating atop the glassy black waters. He wholeheartedly expected them to come too at any moment and swim to shore with the rest of the struggling students… but they never did. Ben himself had been struggling within his flooded cabin, but was pulled from the sinking train by an older student who, of course, Ben did not recognize. The Boy tried to shield as much of the disaster as he could from Ben by cradling his head but there is only so much one person can do against such a large and horrifying sight. Ben never got a chance to thank the older student for saving his life before he was off attending to other students in need. Ben scanned the great hall trying to locate the familiar face… he could not. Most were looking away or in tears. No one seemed to be in very high spirits.
An adult witch rose to stand at the front of the Great Hall with a roll of parchment stretched out in both hands. From it, she read a name:
“Bartimus Arrowbeam.”
No one moved. Ben did not understand what was happening. After a moment of silence, the witch put the parchment away and approached the closest girl and ushered her onto a solitary stool at the front of the Great Hall and placed the hat that had sung the confusing song on top of her head. After a few more moments, the hat announced to the entirety of attendees:
“Hufflepuff!”
What the heck is a huffelpuff? Ben questioned. Ben’s head raced, everything was so confusing… crashing trains, missing students, talking hats, hufflepuffs, dangerous werewolves… Ben thought that there must have been a briefing he missed where they explained what was happening. He felt alone.
Then after the hat called out, a group of students at one of the four long tables clapped and welcomed the timid girl to their ranks. Ben realized that they were being sorted into groups. He felt a wave of warmth wash over him as he witnessed the girl receive an earnest greeting from the welcoming table. These students would soon be welcoming Ben to a table. Despite the craziness of the night’s events, these people were kindly receiving everyone who had never been to Hogwarts before, regardless of whether or not they were from non-magical houses. Regardless of the fact that half of them couldn’t hide their grim expressions or wipe their fresh tears. Ben would soon be welcomed home as well.
At this realization, he couldn't wait to get to the stool and then to his new family located at one of these four tables. At a certain point within the proceedings, a man with who seemed to have trouble walking, took over for the young witch began motioning for students in her stead. At last, Ben was at the front of the line and was ushered to the single seat and had the hat placed atop his head.
“Hmmmmmmmmm…” The hat crooned in Ben’s ear. Ben was not expecting this but at this point, he was not surprised either. “An improbable passion for the extraordinary with enough curiosity to kill a dozen cats…” The hat continued. “Thank you?” Ben replied. “How does your…” he trudged on but was sharply cut off by the hat. “No questions please!, it’s all here in your head. If I indulge you, we will be here until the start of next term” the hat quipped. Ben buried his inquisitions deep within his thoughts. “You are indeed a brave one but have a tendency towards trouble… even bordering on chaos… not exactly the most academic either…”The hat sustained. “Thank you?” Ben replied again, a little unsure of whether or not that was a good thing. “Aw, yes, certainly not the most academic. Your intentions are pure however and your courage for life is resounding. Best be…. Gryffindor!” That hat finished.
A table to the right of where Ben had been sitting applauded and a few of the students stood to welcome him into his new house. Ben also did not know what a Gryffindor was but he took a seat next to one of the girls who had been sorted earlier. Students shook his hand and patted his back as he did so and, although there was still a thick air of solemnness around the Hall, Ben couldn't help but feel the spark re-ignite inside of him.