I don't know why we can't do it without full rosters? I never understood why people hate using NPC's so much. We have enough people interested, on each team, let's just do it. We can devise a system to where a full team is not even needed, again, NPC's can fill their place. Each writer can control said NPC in their own respective post.
This game is only limited by our imagination, and putting any kind of restraint on it because we need one more person is lame, and it is totally not impossible guys. A simple system I can think of right now?
Each team has their opening moves. A lot of this will be dice rolls, but the snitch is released, more on that later. But who gets first possession of the quaffle? So the opening post is after the roll, whoever rolls higher, gets possession of the quaffle. Then they make their offensive moves and they have a few options in their post. They can pass, fly towards the net, or even shoot. Passing is simple, you just pass to someone else, but the the defense has a chance to intercept if they want to. So defense can either post up and try and steal/deflect, or they can try and itercept a pass, beaters can try and hit a bludger towards whoever has the quaffle.
Scoring is simple, you shoot, you roll twice for each team, whoever has the higher dice roll wins. You shoot a bludger at someone? Roll a dice, DICE DICE DICE PEOPLE! Obviously a neutral party rolls the dice, someone who is NOT on either team, that includes alts people.
After every couple of posts two more dice are rolled and when it lands on doubles, the snitch appears, and both seekers can go for it. To catch the snitch you have to roll either two evens in a row or two odds in a row, but it can be deterred. The other person can either roll to catch, or interfere with you, if you are interfered with the other person must roll higher than your first dice roll. If this happens, even if you roll dubs, you still miss the snitch.
Now this is just a very basic system people. I did all of that in five minutes. This is not hard, we can do it, so Jess keep your negativity out of here! ( I am joking with you, I promise,
]