My thing is to do what my character does and to do it well, and what he sucks at, he sucks at. With Brian, he is a prankster through and through, who is also good at Quidditch. His main skill is running away from his pranks or using sneak attacks. The fact of the matter is, if someone came up to him one on one, he would probably lose any type of one on one confrontation. ( He is notoriously lazy and doesn't do homework so his magic skills aren't great. ) So I have to pick and choose my battles wisely. The thing is, I have been trying to cause a lot of IC chaos lately if you guys haven't noticed, mostly because I want it to be spread.
I mean I have attacked Slytherin twice with fireworks and have been hitting on every girl I see. That's the kind of stuff that would be spread around Hogwarts. Back to what Jackles was saying, I don't have to be in the thread to be discussed, I want my actions to reflect all over Hogwarts. I want guys coming after me for hitting on their girlfriends/crush, I want Slytherin's to take revenge on my for my actions, and I don't want to plot it darn it. I want some peeved off Slytherin to see one of my open threads and come in for revenge!
So really I think people should plot less and just go with things, especially at Hogwarts, where anything can happen. You never know how your character is going to react until they get into a situation with another character, and you guys were talking about trusting people more if you know them OOC, well what better way to get to know someone than to write with them?
On the subject of not "losing" the writer really needs to analyze the situation OOC. Are they older, are they stronger, do they have experience, the list goes on and on. Brian isn't going to "win" any duels or fights, but where he lacks in that, he gains in overall bravery and fearlessness and a never give up attitude. Its a balance, you see, I cannot win fights but I keep going back for more. So you have to find, and stick with, what your character is actually good at. I see people breaking character all the time and being either much wittier, smarter, or stronger than they would be in another post just to get an upper hand.
Accountability people.
OK, sorry, I may be sleep and this may have been a rant about nothing.