Righto. I think I'll stick with what I know, address each issue as I see them.
Attendance/Punishment for a lack thereof.
I think that the system you suggested is the best one possible - it's certainly the one I've adapted to my classes, but I believe that we'd be making a very strong move to make this the official view of PA for class attendance, as we'd all prefer for people to turn up late, rather than not turn up at all. Personally, I find that I prefer to give points out to anyone for attending, so that is something I'd also like others' opinions on?
Class regularity
Wholeheartedly agree. Ways we could do this is have the current class up as a sticky thread, then at the end of the two weeks, or w.e. period is chosen, the old class is un-stickied, then the new class is stickied. I personally think that we'd benefit having a break between classes, maybe a week between classes officially "ending" and the new one beginning. So, two weeks of class, break for a week, two weeks of class, break for a week.
The NPC teacher idea is something I'm opposed to - we have too much on our plate as it is I find, however, it'd be worthwhile looking into making the substitute teacher role actually mean something. Too many subs don't ever do anything, despite the fact that the classes sit inactive (Mostly)
Attendance... blah
Not sure what to do with House Points, in all honesty. People have too many characters in too many houses to have much of a house spirit (Prove me wrong people, prove me wrong) An emphasis in House points is desperately needed though, I agree. I'll talk to the Hoggies staff about it.
See in what you said there the issue of a separate timeline is introduced. Thusfar we've chosen to avoid that, simply because it's easier not to have one. that's the basis of it. It's also a lot easier to do christmas and halloween events... at Christmas and Halloween, though maybe it's time we rethought some of those ideas?
As for the punishments for a lack of attendance, we tried doing something along the lines of restricting character freedom, and it flopped - don't want to do it again sorry. Maybe IC detentions are the way to go, then we incorporate that with your NPC idea, and deduct a large amount of house points?
Allowance
We've looked at a stipend based sort of thing, and it's true that monetary restrictions are a great way of pulling them back, in theory... I need to see where the site stands on me jump starting that system before I commit to anything though.
Threat NPC
Great idea, I love it, we must use it. It would be fun to use it just out of the blue. You'd never know which classes would involve the exciting thing.
Reward
I don't know either. It's been a long time since the house points were maintained year round, I've found, and normally when the system falls apart, it doesn't come straight till the next IC year.
Now, to the rest of you. This is not a conversation between Howl and I, instead this is just a conversation we're having with you all. If you have an opinion on anything I've said here, or in any other threads, you're damned right I expect you to voice them. If you don't, we figure that the idea isn't popular, so we just drop it. If you like what's being said here, say it. If you hate it, tell us. If you think it's good, but one thing stands out that you would do in another manner, TELL US.
Or else I'll be sad