For a long time, Frank just listened. He made no comments, from Elijah's musings about kids, to the story of his childhood friend. There was no need to. His hands lay curled around the soft sides of the mug, though he did not lift it to drink. His pinkie vaguely fingered the lace of the doily, his eyelashes met as he blinked every so often, denying th \e world small milliseconds of his kind, brown eyes.
What sort of world had the wizarding world become? They all spoke of how superior they were to muggles, who still lived like savaged.. But what kind of world let a little girl get beaten to death? What kind of world allowed for shells of young boys to exist, numbed of any good feelings? What kind of world took children from parents? Let parents dictate the lives of their young so harshly? No, wizards were absolutely no better. The only thing that set them apart was they routinely carried sticks with them.
A lot of things made sense now. Cecily and her little gang had spoken of Elijah, for he had quite the reputation at Hogwarts. As heartbreaker and heartthrob, dangerously mysterious as a painter, yet easy to get to know if you wanted to. It weirded Frank out that he knew such things of Elijah, things gleamed from the minds of his teenaged fan club, but at least now things made a little more sense. The girl's had made him seem like God's gift, while simultaneously chastising him for his lack of indiscretion. There was thing they had refused to recognize, one thing they had refused to believe he had, because it might alter their oh-so wise and upright opinion of him:
A past.
After Elijah's story, Frank left a few moments to silence, out of respect to the story, respect to Alice's memory, respect to Elijah's pain. Finally, he said something that Elijah needed to hear, something people probably refused to recognize of him. "You really loved her," he stated, as fact and truth. Elijah needed to know that someone believed that.
"You'd do anything for her, wouldn't you?" he asked quietly, staring into his mug. "Anything to honor her, keep her alive. Through you, she lives. But does she live, if you really don't?" He glanced up. "I know it's cliche but it's something that needs to be considered- Would she want you to be in agony? You could devote your entire life to pleasing her by doing as she wished- by living happily, the way I'm sure she'd want you to."