((I am so, so, s0 sorry this took me so long to write. I have just been very busy and I knew this post was going to take me a long time to write, so it had to wait. Sorry again!))
When Amelia finished speaking, Elijah was holding his head in his hands, not even looking at her. After the verbal abuse she had given him, it wasn’t exactly surprising that he should hide the handsome face that had won him so many of the things he held dear. After all, what would Elijah Krum be without his dashing good looks? Amelia was torn between telling him to look at her and just walking out, glad not to have to see his pitiful expression as she did. She wasn’t sure Elijah could even own up to what he had done to her, or even if he was aware of it. After leaving so many people it probably took on a sense of normalcy to desert the people whose lives you had promised to change.
After a few minutes of silence in which Amelia stood gripping the chair and Elijah held his head in his hands, Elijah broken the stagnancy and lifted his head from his hands. He was still not looking at her as he pushed his chair away from the table and stood up, crossing the room to where the burning book lay in the corner, still smoking and glowing with embers, though the flames had died down now. When he reached the tome, he produced his wand and a jet of water to put out the fire that had been burning. It seemed Elijah had decided to tackle the easier fire in the room – i.e. not the hot-tempered redhead that had been bordering on all out shouting at him for the last few minutes. After a few minutes of attention on the book, it seemed to be more or less in one piece, but definitely worse for the wear.
Sort of like someone else we know, Amelia thought scathingly, not in self-pity, but rather in self-actualization. It was still astounding to her just how long she had managed to believe in something that she had been avoiding for the better part of her 17 years of life.
With the book no longer smoldering, Elijah returned to his full height and walked back over to the table, his eyes on the book in his hands instead of on the tense form of Amelia, who still hadn’t moved from her place on the opposite side of the desk. When he was within arm’s reach of the desk, Elijah casually tossed the book onto the table, and although Amelia wanted to seem disinterested, her eyes still fell to the book on the table, if only to find out which collection of knowledge would no longer be a pristine part of the Hogwarts library collection.
The Thrills of Parenthood, Amelia read, her mind not entirely processing the title initially except to wonder why in the world Elijah would be reading that book. In fact, Amelia had never actually seen Elijah read a book, probably because he was too busy wooing women.
Before Amelia could come to the conclusion – which perhaps should have been more obvious, but she was still in an irrational state brought on by her irate feelings that clouded what would otherwise have been a simple logical deduction – Elijah started speaking. His tone was detached, even chilled compared to the heat that had been rolling off Amelia only a few minutes earlier. Amelia immediately scoffed at his first words, but he continued on in spite of her skepticism, clarifying his initial statement with words that were more similar to something she might say than anything she would have ever attributed to Elijah. She didn’t know where he was going with this, but she didn’t have time to ask either. Elijah continued on without waiting for a response, his words becoming more impassioned as he did.
Elijah’s description of himself seemed perfectly apt to Amelia, who couldn’t have agreed more that Elijah’s ‘accomplishments’ weren’t anything all that impressive. She would have said something quite the opposite a few weeks earlier, but she had learned – or rather realized, because she wanted to believe she had known it all along – that what Elijah was saying was the truth.
The fact that he was admitting it, though, was not at all what Amelia had anticipated as a reaction to what she had said to him. She had expected him to get defensive, to tell her to buzz off and leave him alone. She had expected him to curse at her, to take a swing at her, or at the very least to blow her off, but that was not at all the response she was eliciting.
As Elijah continued, he seemed to be changing his tone from one of agreement with Amelia, to the same old story he had been telling her for the last year. This was more what Amelia had been expecting, which helped her to keep her guard up. It didn’t seem to be helping Elijah, though, and for the first time in his grand speech, Elijah seemed to be coming to a loss for words. He stumbled as he tried to explain that he didn’t want to lose her, that he wanted to keep her.
Everyone stumbles when they are trying to come up with a good lie, Amelia’s subconscious chimed in derisively, so quick to believe the worst of the one person she had ever been able to see differently. Oh how things had changed.
Elijah overcame his stumbles before Amelia could express this thought aloud, though, and his topic had changed yet again. His voice was quieter now, and he had, for reasons unbeknownst to Amelia, had brought up his children. Amelia had already met Fauve – a gesture she had thought meant Elijah was growing close to her, but obviously not – but the Ravenclaw girl was completely oblivious to how the girl fit into this conversation at all. And then he was talking about Chase, and a mistake, and…
Oh God.
And there it was. The conclusion Amelia had missed earlier. Although she had almost immediately forgotten about the parenting book when Elijah had started speaking, these new phrases had brought it back to the surface of her mind and the pieces had clicked together even before Elijah mentioned the word baby. He didn’t need to say it. Amelia had already – although belatedly – realized just what had turned Elijah into the invisible man in her life.
Amelia’s legs seemed to lose their tone at this realization, and the redhead surrendered to the chair she had been gripping, though she sat rigidly on the end of it instead of letting it support her from all angles. Elijah was going to have a baby. Chase’s baby. He was going to be a father, and not just to some adopted child this time. This one would be his own flesh and blood, evidence of an act he could not take back. Some part of Amelia’s mind was aware that Elijah was still talking, but Amelia’s mind was too busy coming to terms everything. And there were so many things to dissect. How Elijah had left her for Chase, that he was going to have her child, that she hadn’t realized that sooner. That she would never have him back.
You don’t want him back, Amelia’s mind reminded her, though with less resounding confidence than she had been feeling about the same statement earlier. When she had started this conversation, she had been ready to throw Elijah aside because it was her choice. Now, she had to accept that it wasn’t. The choice had already been made, and she had had nothing to do with it.
“I guess I shouldn’t be surprised,” Amelia said quietly, staring unfocusedly at a patch of the floor where the grout had been scratched away by centuries’ worth of students walking across it, “Considering your promiscuity, there was a statistically significant probability that this would happen.”
She was reverting to logic, to math, to absolute terms. It was a defense mechanism, one she was employing because she didn’t know what else to say. What was she supposed to say? That she was happy for him? She wasn’t. That it wasn’t his fault? It was. That he would make a good father? At this point, Amelia didn’t think he would. Teenage boys did not make good fathers. There were too many factors fighting against the probability of that happening.
“Why did you even tell me this?” Amelia asked, looking back at Elijah for the first time since she had put together the pieces of the picture that Elijah had been subtly hinting at, and then had finally been blatant enough with that Amelia’s usually perceptive mind was able to come to the right conclusion. Looking at him was difficult now, because the anger that had made it possible earlier was no longer the most prominent emotion Amelia was feeling. She didn’t know what to call this new one, or even if this counted as an emotion. Mostly she just felt empty, drained, at a loss. As far as Amelia knew, there were just no words for this.