Of course Elijah would have a retort for that. He has an answer for everything, Amelia’s subconscious fumed, listening to Elijah try to turn the accusations around on her. But he didn’t stop there. No. He kept talking, the way he always did. Amelia used to appreciate the fact that Elijah had 50 words for every one of hers; it had made being around him much easier back when she had believed all the nonsense he spewed on a consistent basis.
It was difficult, looking back on that time in her life, and not just because her life was so drastically different now. Looking back on that always made Amelia cringe because she had gone against so much of what she had believed in, and for what? For a life that Elijah had promised she was capable of leading. She had always said she’d be happier alone. She had her classes, her music, but someone in her life all the time? More trouble than it’s worth, she’d always said. But then Elijah had come in and somehow made her believe something different, and she would forever begrudge him that. Even if he tried using the ‘I miss you’ card, as he was doing right now.
Amelia’s palms were both resting on the table, pushing into it like the wooden surface might give to her will if she pushed hard enough. It was serving as her substitute for pushing Elijah away, though she would very much liked to have done that instead. It seemed that every time he was near her, he somehow managed alternately to hurt her or weasel his way back through her defenses. It was completely illogical that he should be able to do both of those things in succession, and repeatedly. She had to hand it to him: he had a definite knack for talking his way out of or into whatever situation suited him best. He had done it when he returned the shoes, in the owlery, and in the chess park. Each memory was like a clearly defined snapshot for Amelia, and no matter how she tried to forget, they were all there in the back of her mind, as clear as all the others.
Elijah lit the burner beneath her cauldron, beginning the process of heating the water she had filled it with. She was careful not to breathe as he leaned over and did this, because Amelia knew all too well how the scent of Elijah had always been a powerful weapon against her better judgment. When he pulled away, Amelia allowed herself to exhale, which came out as more of a sigh when Elijah asked her yet again to give him another chance.
“Why should I?” Amelia asked plainly, keeping her voice quieter this time because she was all too aware that other students were beginning to take their seats in the dungeon and would easily overhear her if she berated Elijah in the tone she would have liked to use.
“You say you would do it differently, if you had the chance, but you’ve already proven that you wouldn’t,” Amelia said, looking up at Elijah again, this time without the same fiery scorn as before. Now she was just laying out the facts for him; they didn’t need an emotion behind them to prove her point. They did the talking for themselves.
“I gave you a second chance after you ignored me for months without explanation,” Amelia stated, her voice perfectly level as though she were reporting the charges against Elijah in a court of law, “And then you went and disappeared again for months without warning. Then fate saw fit to give you another crack at me in the chess park with Faye, and I actually thought you might give a damn because you saw fit to introduce me to your adopted daughter. So I gave you another chance. A third chance. And what did you do with that? You went and slept with Chase and got yourself a biological daughter.”
Amelia had started speaking plainly, but the farther she got into her story, the more angry she became. That redheaded temper of hers was bubbling to the surface as she stared at Elijah, her whisper becoming a hissing the longer she spoke. She knew that if she kept this up much longer her body would betray her and send that telltale catch into her throat and show Elijah that for all her cold and ice, she had been truly hurt by him, over and over again, and that she still hadn’t recovered. It had been nearly a year, and she still hadn’t convinced herself to forget. She needed to wrap things up before she revealed something she'd regret.
“So if you can give me a reason why I should give you another chance,” Amelia whispered with finality, stressing the word that would really imply just how little he deserved one, “I would really like to hear it.”